
Concerns that the draft Ban Conversion Practices Bill could be misused can be fixed with straightforward changes to its wording. That’s what experts told the Joint Committee scrutinising the Bill today.
Sarah Branson of the Family Law Bar Association told the Committee that the Bill’s definition of ‘abusive’ used language unfamiliar to family lawyers. She said it should line up with the ‘significant harm’ test already used in family law. On fears that the Bill could stop parents having exploratory conversations with their children, she said:
‘There’s a lot of concern about unintended consequences, and that’s what everyone is worried about. And if it’s not the intention of Parliament for open-ended conversations involving exploration, or in the case of social workers, assessment or advice where the purpose is to help the person understand their experiences with no particular conclusion about their identity, then why doesn’t the Bill say that?
‘In the definition of conversion practices, why don’t you just say this is not intended to prohibit open-ended exploration, assessment, and advice within the Bill. It’s fixable, isn’t it?’
Shabana Jaffar, Head of Legal at Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service, agreed that the terminology in the definition was unfamiliar and said the Bill should be clearer about how its thresholds fit with the existing family law system.
Des Johnson, Chair of Trustees at FFLAG, the UK’s longest-established charity for the parents and families of LGBT+ people, agreed.
Des Johnson, Chair of Trustees at FFLAG, said:
‘There is nothing in this Bill, in our opinion, that will have a chilling effect on messy, cautious parenting.
‘Parenting LGBT young people is complicated. Being a parent is complicated. Being a parent of an LGBT+ person is even more complicated. But this Bill specifically seeks to address a compulsion, an extreme reaction, in a minority of parents who feel compelled to change the sexual orientation or gender identity of their child. This is not about a restriction of messy, complicated, distressing conversations.
‘I’ve heard arguments that say these offences are covered under existing law. If that’s the case, then vexatious claims are already happening, and there should be no increase. I would also encourage the Committee to seek evidence from those jurisdictions that already have comprehensive, trans-inclusive conversion practices bans, and ask those jurisdictions for evidence on whether they’ve seen a spike in vexatious claims against parents, religious figures, or therapists. I’ve had a look, and I can find zero evidence that that’s the case. Honestly, it feels to me like it’s scaremongering.
‘I would really encourage us to centre our thinking on the victims, not on trying to protect the rights of potential perpetrators of abuse.’
Nathan Stilwell, Head of Press and Campaign Communications at Humanists UK, said:
‘Today the Committee heard that concerns about misuse and unintended consequences can be met with clear drafting. That is no reason to water down or delay protections for LGBT+ people. Parliament should make it clear that ordinary, loving, and even difficult conversations are not conversion practices. But most importantly, we need a ban that protects everyone, and doesn’t tell LGBT+ people they are wrong and can be cured.’
Notes
For further comment or information, media should contact Humanists UK Head of Press and Campaign Communications Nathan Stilwell at press@humanists.uk or phone 020 3675 0959 (media only).
Read seven facts about banning so-called ‘conversion therapy’
Read our write-up of the previous evidence session: ‘Immensely warranted’: therapy experts welcome ‘conversion therapy’ ban
Read more about our work on ending conversion practices.
Humanists UK is the national charity working on behalf of non-religious people. Powered by over 150,000 members and supporters, we advance free thinking and promote humanism to create a tolerant society where rational thinking and kindness prevail. We provide ceremonies, pastoral care, education, and support services benefiting over a million people every year, and our campaigns advance humanist thinking on ethical issues, human rights, and equal treatment for all.